The urge to make reference to dodgy populist makeover shows and super nanny shows on telly has finally overcome my fear of embarrassment at admitting to watching them. And so I now have let you know that I do believe that Trinny and Susannah hold the key to the future of dementia care.
At the back end of last year I was gripped by the weekly episode of ‘Trinny and Susannah Undress’. Each week they would move in with a couple where one or both were still dressing in the 80’s, or giving up on their appearance and giving way to expanding waistlines and life in Jogging bottoms.
Now I’m certainly no fashion guru (ask my wife) but I thought a lot of the couples had quite some style. However, what fascinated me was the fact that Trinny and Susannah dared to delve to the heart of the relationship between the couple. The shopping for new outfits was almost a side issue as they would ask intimate questions about the couple’s relationship.
They probed into how and why the couple have stayed together and at what first attracted them to each other. They looked too at what couples were feeling about each other now and at what had changed in their relationship (often children and jobs got priority over looking after their own relationship, a sense of identity and self esteem had gone or drastically reduced).
Each week they got to the heart of the relationship, helped couples rekindle the old spark and remind them that being together happily was still possible even with the challenges life was constantly throwing at them and everyone. The show would culminate in the couple literally standing naked in front of each other (behind a screen of course). I was amazed each week at how Trinny and Susannah could persuade the couple to do this. It was clearly as a result of them daring to broach certain subjects and getting a positive response – they were dealing with people who were truly relieved that they were being helped to focus on awkward topics.
I hope you are still with me on this. Ask yourselves what exactly do we see each week in our work? Do we not wince when we visit couples who are constantly at each others’ throats because one doesn’t understand the behaviour of the other? I regularly see people questioning the validity of decades of marriage because they can’t understand why their partner is rounding on them. What do we do about it? We separate people. We send one off to respite or day care or into hospital for assessment. Then we send people back together equally ill-equipped to cope with the same unattended antagonisms. We resign ourselves to the fact that nothing can be done about a couple whom we perceive to be ‘always fighting’. This then becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. I have studied and tried out a relationship-centred approach to care and I have shared my findings in the Journal of Dementia Care (Murphy 2006). I found, as did Trinny and Susannah, that people want to talk about what’s important to them. It gets results. People are helped to focus on why they are together and they can be united against the dementia. They are relieved to broach subjects together as a couple in a safe environment (much less public than on national television!).
So like Trinny and Susannah, all front line workers in dementia care need to be equipped to carry out relationship-centred work, to broach subjects that to some may seem awkward. Otherwise we remain with the tea and sympathy approach and the usual crop of services. We have constant contact with people with dementia and their carers so we need to enhance the quality of that contact. Far too often I found myself in somebody’s house, seeing a couple struggle living together with dementia, witnessing personal detractions (usually with no ill-intent) and pointless argument. I was usually there for another reason and usually had another appointment 10 minutes later. So the matter could not be addressed and the couple would carry on in this spiral of mutual self-destruction.
People with dementia and their carers can live with dementia rather than suffer from it. We need to be aware of the change in dynamic of a relationship that occurs with the presence of an illness in the family. For too long now dementia care has tended to focus on the individual (person with dementia or carer) and their unique set of problems rather than the family system and how it has adapted to whatever illness is present. The recent push for early diagnosis gathers pace while innovative service provision to match that still lags behind and a lot of usual offerings tend perpetuate the separatist approach. To explain, let me tell you of another telly programme I love.
‘The House of Tiny Tearaways’ is one of those super nanny programmes where child psychologist expert professor Whatsername works with families with ‘problem’ toddlers. They live together for a week and talk about the whole family system and about the feelings of every member. Everyone is included and specific strategies are tried out.
It always makes me laugh because I immediately think of how these families would be dealt with by the current dementia care model. The child would be sent away for a couple of weeks to a home so parents could have a break. No work would be carried out with anybody and they would be expected to cope better once the child returned.
Adopting such a model in children’s services would rightly cause a national outcry. Why, then, do we tolerate this in older people’s services? Are we content to allow the gaps between respite shorten every time until long term care ensues or can we act to equip families to live with dementia longer in the community?
How about improving the mental well-being of people with dementia and their carers to enable and equip them to live together with dementia?
How about breaking the taboo that ‘dementia’ or ‘Alzheimer’s’ is in our psyche?
How about including people with dementia in all aspects of their assessment, diagnosis and care?
How about promoting awareness of the fact that dementia is eminently ‘liveable-with’.
A leaf out of Trinny and Susannah’s book would be a great place to start. Now I’m just off out to buy a pair of crimplene slacks I’ve spotted – they’ll make me look HOT.
Murphy D. (2006) Relationship-centred work with couples. Journal of Dementia Care 14(1) 35-37